Last summer I pulled our boat up the last grade before the lake, the one that bends right before the boat ramp turnoff, and I felt the truck give up about two-thirds of the way through it. Not stall-out give up, just that slow fade where the pedal is on the floor and the speedometer is losing the argument anyway.
My father-in-law was behind me in his diesel truck with a camper twice the weight of my boat and trailer combined, and he came up that same hill without ever dropping out of the passing lane. I spent the rest of that drive doing the math on what he was driving that I wasn’t.
That math comes down to one word: torque.
It’s the number that decides what happens the moment you point a loaded trailer at a hill, and it’s the number most first-time tow vehicle shoppers never ask about, because horsepower gets all the attention on the window sticker.
Gas vs. Diesel Starts With What You Are Really Towing
When considering gas vs. diesel trucks for towing, before anything else, figure out the real number.
What do I mean by number?
No, not the brochure number for your boat or camper. It’s the number for the loaded weight of what you are towing once you’ve added fuel, water, gear, and whatever you or the previous owner left bolted to the frame. For example, a 24-foot bowrider boat with a full tank and gear aboard tows very differently than the same boat listed dry on a spec sheet, and the gap gets wider with a travel trailer once it’s loaded for a two-week trip instead of a weekend getaway.
Once you have the loaded weight data, the question of gas versus diesel stops being about brand loyalty and starts being about physics.
If your boat or camper is wondering if your truck even exists due to loss of towing ability, it may be that your vehicle may not have the towing power at the RPM range it needs it.
A gas engine generates its peak power high in the RPM range, which means it has to rev to get there, and revving hard while towing a loaded trailer on a grade is the one situation where a gas engine starts to feel like it’s working against itself.
Conversely, a diesel engine makes most of its pulling power low in the RPM range, right where a loaded trailer needs it. That’s the difference between the two trucks that were sitting side by side at the ramp (well, once I actually arrived at the ramp).
Why Torque Wins on the Hills That Matter
Torque is what gets a loaded trailer moving from a dead stop and what keeps a truck climbing steadily without having to downshift and rev to find more power.
A diesel engine is built around that low-end pulling force from the ground up, and it shows up where towing gets hard: pulling away from a boat ramp on an incline, merging onto a highway with a loaded camper behind you, or holding speed on a long grade without the transmission desperately searching other gears, looking for enough power to get the job done.
That’s the gap my father-in-law’s truck was showing me on that hill that day. His diesel wasn’t working any harder than mine. It simply had more pulling force available at the RPM where a loaded trailer needs it. As a result, the truck never had to strain to keep climbing.
What Changes Once Towing Becomes Routine
A lot of families that love the great outdoors end up in the same spot. The truck was fine for the first season of light towing, and then the boat got bigger, or a large camper got added into the mix, or towing stopped being an occasional weekend thing and became every other weekend from Spring through Fall.
That’s usually the point where an owner starts noticing the same fade I felt on that hill. And, even if you already own a diesel truck, you might start asking whether there’s a way to get more out of your current truck, instead of trading up to a bigger one.
That’s where a tuner comes into the conversation.
A tuner adjusts the calibration the engine and transmission use to respond to load, throttle input, and grade, and for a truck doing real towing, what matters most is how much of that low-end pulling force the calibration lets the engine use. Factory tunes are written conservatively for a wide range of drivers, most of whom never load a trailer anywhere close to what a family with a boat and a camper will pull behind the truck.
The question at that point isn’t whether the truck can pull more. It’s whether the calibration it left the factory with is letting it. A diesel tuner built to boost towing torque is the usual answer. So, if your truck is already working weekends and towing on grades, finding out whether your calibration is hindering you is the question that needs answering.
Best Outdoor Lifestyle Apparel!
-
The N1 Outdoors® “OUTDOORS™” Tee
$15.00 -
N1 Outdoors® Fishscape™ Outdoor Tee
Price range: $28.99 through $32.99 -
N1 Outdoors® Duck Camo Block Logo Heavyweight Hoodie
$34.00
Matching the Upgrade to the Truck in the Driveway
The part that trips people up when deciding to buy a tuner is assuming that they all work the same, regardless of what diesel vehicle they have.
They don’t.
A tuner built for one engine code, transmission, and model year does not transfer to a different year of the same truck, even with the same badge on the tailgate And, loading the wrong tuner file is how an owner can end up not only with a truck that doesn’t tow better, but also shifting oddly or throwing a fault code the week before a trip.
So, the key information you need to find out before buying a tuner is not the regarding brand or price. More importantly, does the tuner listing name your engine code and model year, or, just your truck brand?
EngineGo, for example, sorts its tuner catalog by engine and model year rather than by the nameplate on the truck bed. A buyer can find this information in about 60 seconds, giving the buyer confidence that they are purchasing the right tuner. If you don’t see the information on the tuner listing that tells you what engine and model of vehicle that the tuner is for, and you can’t get that answer from the seller, you may want to consider buying elsewhere.
Back at the Ramp
I didn’t trade my truck in after that hill. I looked into what was different about the diesel my father-in-law was driving, and torque was the honest answer. Not horsepower, not brand, but rather how much pulling force was available at the RPM where towing happens.
If your outdoorsy family is closer to towing every other weekend than towing twice a year, that’s the number to consider before the next trip to the lake, rather than after a hill takes the fight out of your truck the way that one took it out of mine!
